See what’s changing in Firefox: Better insights, same privacy | The Mozilla Blog
blog.mozilla.org
Innovation and privacy go hand in hand here at Mozilla. To continue developing features and products that resonate with our users, we’re adopting a new a

To disable it in about:config

browser.search.serpEventTelemetry.enabled  =  false	
browser.search.serpEventTelemetryCategorization.enabled  =  false
  • @Vincent@feddit.nl
    2•7 months ago

    So which organisation with many userse serves the needs of their users better without collecting data?

    • kbal
      3•7 months ago

      Most free software does not have telemetry, and when it does it’s almost always opt-in. Firefox is the one major exception to that rule.

      • @Vincent@feddit.nl
        1•7 months ago

        Hmm, so what user-facing free software is at Firefox’s scale? I think Ubuntu has telemetry, for example (though I think they even have fewer users).

        • kbal
          2•7 months ago

          Ubuntu telemetry is fairly minimal, as of last time I used it a few years ago. Not remotely comparable to what firefox does. They just want to know what hardware you have, there’s no user behaviour tracking, and it’s fully opt-in (you have to deliberately turn it on when installing). KDE and Gnome have a little something like that as well now, I think. Almost everything else does not.

          Debian has a list (last updated 2023-10) of software among the 97000 packages they distribute which have been found to violate user privacy by “phoning home” for telemetry or other purposes:

          • gnome-calculator - fetches currencies
          • Firefox - multiple issues
          • Thunderbird - opt-out telemetry that is not yet patched for Debian
          • Chromium - phones home in various ways
          • syncthing - version check and lots more
          • cura - phones home in various ways, patched out in Debian
          • azure-cli - collects “anonymous” telemetry by default
          • glances - connects to several online services to discover public IP
          • webext-bulk-media-downloader - loads the website and sends version info
          • Golang - planning on implementing enabled-by-default telemetry
          • @Vincent@feddit.nl
            2•7 months ago

            there’s no user behaviour tracking

            I mean, that depends on how you define user behaviour. It tracks which packages are frequently installed, for example, or how often people install Ubuntu in the first place. All of which I think is pretty legit, in my opinion, since that only involves aggregate user statistics that help prioritise work and detect common problems - but that’s essentially what Firefox is doing too.

            Debian is a great example of relatively commonly used free software that doesn’t really collect data btw.

            • kbal
              1•7 months ago

              Canonical apparently turned on enabled-by-default telemetry for new installs in 2018 which records basic system hardware stats and such. It’s not that much compared to what Firefox sends, but adding it still did damage to their reputation.

              Another thing Ubuntu has in common with Firefox is a continuing long-term decline in market share. As they do things like adding telemetry, flirting with the idea of putting advertising in the package manager, insisting that everyone use snap, et cetera, users have started to go elsewhere. As I did.

              In the case of Ubuntu though, the company’s main business is in serving their corporate customers. If it’s little-used by the rest of us the company might still do well, as I hope they continue to do. Firefox does not share that advantage.